A Question on Grouping Notes Options

[harrylau]

As in the AB guide said, "the standard practice is to avoid ties where possible". Now I have a simple song (for vocalist) which contains a lot of off-beats, as shown below:

(IMG:http://dl.dropbox.com/u/17730810/score01.png)

A is following the AB guide rule while B is easier to count the beats.

Which one is correct (or better), A or B? If B, do I need to beam the quavers in the third beat in bars 1,5 and 6?

Thank you for your help! (IMG:style_emoticons/default/smile.gif)

[Neumer]

As you say, B is more correct.

When I studied composition, most of the tutors agreed that if you have an awkward bar that can convey the meaning of your writing better to the performer, it's quite normal to stray from strict convention. Ease of performing being the important thing.

For me, I'd go for version B in bar 1 (clearer across the bar), then version A in bar 5, and version B again in bar 6. [odd bar numbering by the way]

Also, I suppose it's also important to think what it's being notated for. If formal educational purposes, check with a tutor for the policy on such an issue. For your own purposes, use common sense and discretion, keeping the performer in mind.

Hope this helps.

N