QUOTE(andante_in_c @ Jul 11 2009, 11:49 PM)

QUOTE(kerioboe @ Jul 11 2009, 10:42 PM)

A fairly random remark about something which is bugging me at the moment.
I have never had a problem playing scales from memory on the piano or until now on the oboe but my brain is currently refusing to co-operate for a handful of melodic minors. I have always thought of melodic minors as going up in the tonic major with a flattened 3rd note and coming down in the relative major but for some reason on the oboe I can't seem to "mentally" swap from flats to sharps when I get to the top (ie in scales like C# minor where I want to think of going up in Db and coming back down in E).
If I'm teaching pupils to use this method I suggest they think in C# major rather than Db major. Then every note is sharp on the way up except for the 3rd.
I did think about relearning Db major as C# but that doesn't seem to be much easier. Initially I learnt the major scales (and some of the minors) by visualising the pattern on the piano keyboard before playing them on the oboe and the majors are now sufficiently fluent that I don't actually think about the note names, my fingers just play them. I can play the melodics with the scale book in front of me (which is what my teacher expects me to do anyway) so I think I shall just carry on like that and hope that eventually the fingering becomes automatic enough not to need to think about names.