Think I'll have a permanent "season ticket" to this thread
I have a feeling I'm suffering from a mental disorder called "organistus criticus". ..... I seem to find myself in the company of other organists whose "performance factors" are very BELOW parr, and yet seem to be never short of engagements and praise from audiences.
3 weeks ago I shared the concert platform with a fellow organist

at a well known theatre organ venue.
He opened the proceedings.I can truly say that he must have gone to the "Les Dawson School of Harmony". He announced with pride that he was about to play "for our delight" a selection from the best musical ever written - "My Fair Lady" - proceeded to murder the aforementioned "Fair Lady" and even included (WHY???

) the tune "Feed The Birds" from "Mary flamin'n Poppins" !!!
Anything that hinted of a key change was by-passed in a way that only demonstration could convey the buttock-scrunching embarrasment suffered by me, waiting in the wings to "follow that"
and then, when I was my turn to "make an entry", had to thank "mr X" for and wonderful opening to the concert
At least, I've been asked to play again next year.........ON MY OWN!!!
.............................then, as if t'were not enough, J and I went to a concert (as audience members) where the organist proceeded to commit multiple musical murder with incorrect melody lines, incorrect (boy, HOW incorrect harmonies) and no idea how to end a piece and, and, and.......................
Why is it that some organists - classical, theatre, electronic - seem to rival Harold Shipman when it comes to music and yet get away with it. Do the audience not realize, oris it a case of the "King's New Clothes"
I played for a wedding last month. The grand-daughter of one of my pupils wanted to walk down the aisle to the Wedding Processional from the Sound of Music, and out of church to the "Trumpet Voluntary" and I was aksed to play those items. My pupil (gran) was going to play the rest of the musical content on her own electronic organ taken into the church for the occasion. I was to use the ppe organ.
There was another wedding following, and the regular organist, whom I had never met before was going to play so I hung around to "check him out" - AAAAAAAAAAAAAARRRRRRRRGGGGGGGHHHHHHHH
Poor Happy Couple - watch out for a "Youve Been Framed" video - their ceremony ruined beyond belief by incompetence personifed at the console - and he's been organist for 17 years!!!
Is there a Doctor in the house? Telll me it's not terminal
SCREAM, SCREAM AND
DOUBLE SCREAM