QUOTE(Jazzman340 @ Mar 14 2006, 05:26 PM)

As I sometimes drop the odd bombshell, I think I am expect to say something like this:
The current Jazz grades are all over the place already, so before making G6 7 8, they should make a decent 12345.
And before people become defensive and say go on prove it, you do it, how can they, they're fine blabla... Have a look at the 5 books, all lined up, and compare what is required of each student in each piece. There are G1 pieces that are harder than G4. I don't have the books at hand, but I'm saying it as I've notced it, and having worked for a year in a music shop which specialised in sheet-music, I am quite sure i am not making it up!
Oh i think this is nonsense, having taught the jazz syllabus (trumpet, trombone, saxophone and clarinet) from the outset the grades are very progressive in levels of dificulty yes you might find the odd piece thats seems a little out of place but this could be said about any of the other syllabus's, for example their is a Bach grade 8 piece presently on the classical syllabus that would be much more suited to grade 5 or 6 but as a whole the jazz grades work very well. I like the jazz the jazz syllabus, i'm getting a bit bored of teaching the same limited repertoire however and would like the Board to add some new material to the present syllabus, the only saving grace is that i never hear two solos that sound the same. Some of my students have become fantastic improvisers, and some are ok but thats very much the nature of it.