QUOTE(lizbun @ Nov 17 2006, 10:22 AM)

QUOTE(Charlies Aunt @ Nov 17 2006, 10:21 AM)

Is this with the bottle lid on or off?

securly on
No it shoudn't float for any plastic bottle full of water will have a greater specific gravity than water itself.
However there are ways of making something heavier than water float.
You can make a dressmaking pin float. First lay a piece of loo paper on the still surface of the water, and carefully place the pin on the paper . The paper should sink and the pin stay on the surface, held by surface tension. If you then drop a spot of detergent into the water the surface tension lowers and the pin will sink.