Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Which Of There Do You Prefer To Play A Piece/scales In?
Forums > Viva Network > Viva Strings
Chaos_91
It is commonly said that strings find passages with flats in the key signature harder to play than sharps, however I find that flats are easier (More than likely because I am awkward and always seem to find easy things difficult and hard things pretty much ok laugh.gif)

Which do you prefer to play in?

P.s. Ignore the which of there LOL it should be which of these tongue.gif
sarah-flute
On the violin - definitely sharps...

on viola... hmmm it depends

on cello - ask me when I've played pieces with a few more sharps or flats in lol
lizbun
Sharps...
AmandaL
On the violin and viola - sharps.
Morgan's Munchkin
On violin I prefer sharps. On Flute and Recorders I prefer flats.

On piano I get scared by either!!
gummidge
sharp scales on violin and viola.
Flat scales piano, accordion and organ
purple viola
For me, on violin and viola, it depends on the number of sharps or flats in the key signature.

Up to four sharps or flats - sharps
Four or more sharps or flats - flats
cat_loves_flute
On flute sharps. I hate flats!
On violin neither - i forget they're there!

Why can't everything be in C!?
lizbun
QUOTE(cat_loves_flute @ May 15 2007, 01:30 PM) *

On flute sharps. I hate flats!
On violin neither - i forget they're there!

Why can't everything be in C!?



Don't know. Maybe it's becuase some mad person invented scales and/or key signatures.
SueHM
I'm always more comfortable with flats somehow (pianist). I find them easier to read and they feel more mellow than those nasty little sharps!
lottie
I must be weird - I prefer flats blink.gif

Or should that be;

I prefer flats ergo I must be weird???? laugh.gif wacko.gif
kerioboe
Until a few months ago my daughter had played only sharps on the cello and only flats on the trombone. She had therefore quite logically concluded that stringed instruments had sharps and instruments you blow into had flats. She was most perturbed when her cello teacher produced a piece of music which had a Bflat in it and her whole theory collapsed.
cellocase
QUOTE(kerioboe @ May 17 2007, 10:12 PM) *

Until a few months ago my daughter had played only sharps on the cello and only flats on the trombone. She had therefore quite logically concluded that stringed instruments had sharps and instruments you blow into had flats. She was most perturbed when her cello teacher produced a piece of music which had a Bflat in it and her whole theory collapsed.

biggrin.gif biggrin.gif

I prefer flats myself. Nicer sound, somehow!
janexxx
Sharps for the major
Flats for the minor

(just to be awkward)

I hate having 4 of them, would rather have a shedful than 4. That D catches me out everytime.
flute fanatic
Flats!!
Devil_Fiddler
QUOTE(SueHM @ May 16 2007, 12:15 AM) *

I'm always more comfortable with flats somehow (pianist). I find them easier to read and they feel more mellow than those nasty little sharps!


I agree, sharps somehow seem more work to me.
wannabe
I prefer sharps, flats are rather depressing!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.