Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Just A Quickie...
Forums > ABRSM > General Music Forum
piello
Just done a bit of a theory paper and was writing for SATB. i had the bass on a D, tenor on Bb, alto on F and was given the Sop. on a D. So this makes a Bbmajor chord, 1st inversion.
Except my teacher has said it's 2nd inversion. But i'm sure it's first.....could someone just confirm for me?
Thanks! biggrin.gif
piello
sbhoa
1st inversion.
Bb in the bass is root position.
D is first inversion and F 2nd inversion.
piello
biggrin.gif Thanks Sbhoa. That's as i thought then..
bourdon16
But you have doubled the 3rds! [Usually this is bad news but can occasionally happen if the outer parts move in contrary motion]

Not knowing your teacher [who may just have made a mistake or had a senior moment] there could be folk who think the given D at the top means it is 2nd inversion. Thinking of 3 note chords for a moment, I reason thus: Bb D F = root. Put the Bb at the top and you have 1st inversion = D F Bb. Now put the D at the top and you have 2nd inversion F Bb D.

HOWEVER, HOWEVER, HOWEVER!!!!! Positions of triads are worked out from what is at the Bottom NOT what is at the top. So D Bb F and D F Bb are both 1st inversion. In 4 parts, Bass D, Tenor Bb Alto F and Sop F is 1st inversion and so on and so forth.


piello
Thanks, sorry! I meant a Bb at the top. woops. i think i was reading in the wrong clef. But yes, that makes sense, so thanks! smile.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.