piello
Jun 9 2007, 12:50 PM
Just done a bit of a theory paper and was writing for SATB. i had the bass on a D, tenor on Bb, alto on F and was given the Sop. on a D. So this makes a Bbmajor chord, 1st inversion.
Except my teacher has said it's 2nd inversion. But i'm sure it's first.....could someone just confirm for me?
Thanks!
piello
sbhoa
Jun 9 2007, 12:55 PM
1st inversion.
Bb in the bass is root position.
D is first inversion and F 2nd inversion.
piello
Jun 9 2007, 12:58 PM

Thanks Sbhoa. That's as i thought then..
bourdon16
Jun 9 2007, 02:08 PM
But you have doubled the 3rds! [Usually this is bad news but can occasionally happen if the outer parts move in contrary motion]
Not knowing your teacher [who may just have made a mistake or had a senior moment] there could be folk who think the given D at the top means it is 2nd inversion. Thinking of 3 note chords for a moment, I reason thus: Bb D F = root. Put the Bb at the top and you have 1st inversion = D F Bb. Now put the D at the top and you have 2nd inversion F Bb D.
HOWEVER, HOWEVER, HOWEVER!!!!! Positions of triads are worked out from what is at the Bottom NOT what is at the top. So D Bb F and D F Bb are both 1st inversion. In 4 parts, Bass D, Tenor Bb Alto F and Sop F is 1st inversion and so on and so forth.
piello
Jun 9 2007, 02:27 PM
Thanks, sorry! I meant a Bb at the top. woops. i think i was reading in the wrong clef. But yes, that makes sense, so thanks!