QUOTE(AntonPiano @ May 11 2008, 06:44 PM)

The flautist in the Young Musician of the Year 08 selection.
The Scottish guy?
Impressed indeed.
I was impressed greatly, don't get me wrong...but, I mean I'm no expert (far from it) but having watched the concerto performances last night, the others (unless I missed it) seemed to play from memory- including the 12year old who went on to win it, but Flautist guy had music. I realise that he's an amazing musician etc and heaps better than the likes of me, but why couldn't he play without the music- I mean if you've got to the standard of being in the young musician final...
I'm probably just picky, and i'm not disputing how great or un-great(bad english sorry) he was, cus if I closed my eyes and just listened it was breathtaking, but when I opened my eyes and saw him with music when the others did not, it put a damper on things a bit...
there we go, pickyness over...I would love to be anywhere near that great but, it did effect my critical thinking/judgement.