
I have one like that already!!! There are no altos; well there are of course but they all like to call themselves sopranos, and some of them insist on growling an octave below the others. There aren't really enough men to divide into tenors and basses so we have Ladies 1, Ladies 2 and Men. Last weel I told the growlers to try to sing in the correct octave and that if they felt that they couldn't I would show them how to do so with the aid of a hat pin.
The line from Strawberry Fair that runs "My face is my fortune Sir, she said" just didn't work at all for me when sung in the baritone register.
They do try hard though to be fair.