QUOTE(Flossie @ Jul 29 2009, 11:33 PM)

QUOTE(bobziekins @ Jul 29 2009, 11:25 PM)

One quick question, out of interest, whereabouts do you have your thumb on the right hand when you play the flute?
Underneath the f key? Or to the side of the f key, nearest to you? Does the flute rest on the side of the thumb, or the pad, or does the thumb just push against the side of the flute?
On the flute, I have my RH thumb on the side. I have it straight with a slight cuve outwards. It kind of sits near the key above the F key. The bit of my thumb that's opposite my thumbnail is what I have against the flute, not sure whether it pushes or not (I'm not quite sure how to describe what I do

). I also have my headjoint turned in more than a lot of people and have the rods higher. This is how my flute balances best and how it plays best for me - but everyone's different with this kind of thing.
Are you looking at changing your flute hold?
Yeah. My thumbs are double jointed, so my teacher was worried that I wasn't holding it properly, and I'm really not on the right hand, my hand sort of caves in around the flute, and my wrist bends backwards
She didn't really know what I was doing (she's blind), so we went up to this amazing flute shop today, where I got the picc, and one of the shopowners who is also double jointed talked to me about how to hold it. (He's a brilliant flautist and teacher)
He said there should be three points where you hold it, it should be supported on the chin, then push towards you with the lower part of your left index finger, and push away with your right thumb- and this would keep it steady, especially when playing c#
And he said it didn't matter that the thumb bend backwards, because it should push on the side of the flute, under the f key. And he stuck a sticker where my thumb should touch, to remind me. And that my fingers should be straight-ish with a little curve, so the pads touch the keys.
Now I've got it home, it's speeded up my fingers, and helped my wrist. But my little finger really really hurts when I do it, so although it looks right, it hurts after a while.
I just wanted some extra opinions on what everyone else does