QUOTE(Robodoc @ Aug 20 2009, 06:51 PM)

QUOTE(Chopinzee @ Aug 17 2009, 08:26 PM)

I know the feeling Robodoc. Lots of music i start i don't quite finish, . . .
That depends what you mean by "finish". There is a sense in which no music is ever finished.
However, from the pieces I mentioned I can already play the Liszt and the Szymanowski from memory, at the required tempii and with dynamics, articulation, pedalling and rubato more or less as I want it to be and in front of an audience - it really is just fine tuning and trying to get them even more secure.
The Bach prelude I can play from memory (even with my eyes closed) and I am currently making sure that my articulation of the quavers in particular is accurate: The fugue is well on the way to being memorised and I am working on making sure I can bring out any of the four voices at will and that the chords aren't arpeggios(!). By the time I get back to lessons in September I have no doubt that the fugue will have been memorised and both prelude and fugue should be reasonably secure. From that point of view these pieces may be regarded as finished in that it will be more profitable to move on to something else rather than carry on with them.
The Chopin I can play through at speed but the accuracy is still wanting, the voicing of some sections is poor, some jumps are insecure, the variations in rubato are inartistic, the pedaling is heavy handed etc. and I have not accurately committed the whole to memory: Again, by September I probably will have dealt with these things, although my teacher may want me to spend a week or two polishing some bits that she wants me to change. On the whole I expect she will want me to move on - again, not finished (never finished) but enough done to move on.
The Haydn 1st movement is finished in the same sense as the Chopin, and the 2nd and 3rd movements really contain little challenging except the chore of memorisation: Given that I will get little real advantage out of staying with it I expect she will want me to move on here too: Not finished, but finished enough.
I very rarely start out a piece and then move on without "finishing" it: At the very least "finished" means I can play it reasonably accurately, at a reasonable tempo and with required phrasing etc. My teacher doesn't give me stuff to learn unless it is a challenge, so once the challenge is met we move on.
I think you'll find plenty of challenge in that Haydn 3rd movement if you play it, as marked, Presto. And I would try using my feet for the pedals - hands are better employed on the keyboard
But seriously I am impressed (for other forum members - I have heard some of it, and it is very good).
After forty-odd years of playing, I still can't play ANYTHING properly. Out of the many hours worth of memorized piano stuff in my brain I think there is maybe a Bach prelude that I can play pretty near perfectly - at least as well as any of the famous people I've heard play it. Then again ... maybe not.
Also, since I got really serious about piano the rate at which I learn pieces has slowed to a snail's pace. I can (with work) play pretty much anything I put my mind to, and at some time in the past I have sight read through most of the standard repertoire, and analyzed a few to death to see how the composers work their magic ... so the only point in studying any piece now is to be able to perform it.
There is no point in performing something unless you can make it in some way a significant experience for your listeners. To do that demands a deep understanding of the piece, and a very secure performance. When you really study any worthwhile composition it turns out that there is an awful lot in it. It can easily take months to properly understand a Bach Fugue or a Beethoven sonata movement. On top of that it takes twenty times more (a considered estimate) work to memorize something well enough to stand up to performing in front of a paying audience, than it takes to memorize it well enough to play it for your teacher, spouse, parents, or friends. The work that goes into two 45 minute sessions for a full recital is mind-boggling for ordinary mortals - at least if you do it properly. Oh to be a Rubinstein, Hoffman, or Gieseking
Rosalyn Tureck once told an interviewer that when she was a conservatoire student she was working at the (astonishing) rate of memorizing three Bach Preludes and Fugues a week, alongside other repertoire. Then something happened to her, and she had deep insights into the nature of the music. After that the most she could manage was four lines of a fugue ina week - but the level at which she played it was now light years beyond what she had been satisfied with before ...
Anyway ... What I really wanted was an excuse to say is ... if anyone found any of my old postings useful, like, for example pedalling techniques, memorisation, or how to (use/not use) Hanon, overcoming performance nerves, etc. .... then please take copies of them in the next couple of weeks, because as soon as I have finished trawling through them and have copied everything of value back to my Mac I shall be deleting the original posts from the forum, prior to de-registering.