QUOTE(barry-clari @ Sep 26 2009, 08:50 AM)

QUOTE(anacrusis @ Sep 26 2009, 01:52 AM)

*yes, I know I could just play it with the descant fingerings, but the point of having a contrabass is to learn how to read bass clef on recorders. Can anyone tell me why it's so difficult, when I've been able to read bass clef on a piano for years?
Katyjay came up with an idea, that worked for me.
I think you're like me anacrusis : the moment you see a single stave, your mind automatically says 'treble clef'. Katyjay suggested reading from the score (so it looked more piano-like). That made it easier for me.

Having said that, I'm not going to be able to do that for 'cello...

thanks for that, Barry, I'll see if that helps - can quite see how it might

..*tries to think of way to get round that with cello, but concludes that turning the music upside down might not work that well*
QUOTE(andante_in_c @ Sep 26 2009, 09:22 AM)

I learned descant recorder first, when I was nine, and treble at 11. I didn't start flute until 14. Nevertheless, F fingerings are like a fluent second language for me, whilst C fingerings are mother-tongue. I tend to play treble by dots converting to fingerings without thinking of the note name in between. So bass clef F fingerings become like trying to translate a second language into a third, if that makes sense?
Yes, it makes complete sense....now can anyone remember how many languages it is that one needs to know before new ones become super-easy to learn? Only I'm still hankering after that voice flute

, which would add a further set of hurdles

.
Have had a very recordery day today - after demonstrating the acoustics at St Cecila's this morning, I've been playing Telemann church cantata things, some Corelli and a Handel trio sonata with another recorder player, a bassoonist and a harpsichordist

.