QUOTE(RoseRodent @ Oct 26 2009, 07:11 PM)

QUOTE(T.W. Adorno @ Oct 26 2009, 12:36 AM)

Whereas I don't hold too much confidence in many instrumentalists who are largely self-taught (with a few exceptions), isn't music theory fairly easy to teach yourself with the various workbooks available?
Not at this stage, as there are no clear-cut answers and thus the workbooks have no answers in them for you to check you have understood. You can do the whole workbook and be as clueless as you ever were and not know it.
Just a thought, if everyone who has taken the teaching diplomas needs at least grade 6, 8 for the higher ones, how come none of them can teach this higher grade theory stuff? My first teacher had a diploma and clearly knew naff all about theory, even at grade 5 stuff.
I got a distinction at grade 6 7 and 8 theory but I wouldn't feel awfully confident teaching theory at this level.
I think that it's at least partly that unlike theory up to grade 5 this is not what I'd call 'everyday' theory.
Some people may have done the required grade theory soley to gain access to the diploma and been satisfied with just enough to get a pass mark in the same way as many do with grade 5. Ok... a pass is a pass but even with 66% in theory you can have an awful lot of gaps in your knowledge and understanding and still get that certificate.
The later grades (for me at least) were where I learned skills and concepts that I don't actually use on a regular basis.
I'd be prepared to help somebody if there were no other options for them but I'd need at least to do some good revision.