Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: staccato without tonguing
Forums > Viva Network > Viva Woodwind
alij
When notating for a woodwind player, a staccato passage where tonguing between notes is not required, do I show a slur as well as the staccato marks? If not, how do I notate this?
I hope someone can help me. Thanks very much.
ChrisC
QUOTE(alij @ Nov 22 2011, 11:15 AM) *

When notating for a woodwind player, a staccato passage where tonguing between notes is not required, do I show a slur as well as the staccato marks? If not, how do I notate this?
I hope someone can help me. Thanks very much.

I'm not quite sure what you mean. For wind players, notes which have a slur and dots usually indicates "soft tonguing", which couldn't be described as staccato. I'm not sure how a wind player could play staccato without tonguing - it's kind of possible, but probably wouldn't sound very good.

Chris
Celloman26
QUOTE(ChrisC @ Nov 22 2011, 11:22 AM) *

QUOTE(alij @ Nov 22 2011, 11:15 AM) *

When notating for a woodwind player, a staccato passage where tonguing between notes is not required, do I show a slur as well as the staccato marks? If not, how do I notate this?
I hope someone can help me. Thanks very much.

I'm not quite sure what you mean. For wind players, notes which have a slur and dots usually indicates "soft tonguing", which couldn't be described as staccato. I'm not sure how a wind player could play staccato without tonguing - it's kind of possible, but probably wouldn't sound very good.

Chris


Hi Alij,

its not really possible to play staccato notes without tongueing; Chris is absolutely right with the soft tonguing notation (slurs with dots underneath - this messed with my head for many years!).
Arundodonuts
QUOTE(Celloman26 @ Nov 22 2011, 11:34 AM) *

QUOTE(ChrisC @ Nov 22 2011, 11:22 AM) *

QUOTE(alij @ Nov 22 2011, 11:15 AM) *

When notating for a woodwind player, a staccato passage where tonguing between notes is not required, do I show a slur as well as the staccato marks? If not, how do I notate this?
I hope someone can help me. Thanks very much.

I'm not quite sure what you mean. For wind players, notes which have a slur and dots usually indicates "soft tonguing", which couldn't be described as staccato. I'm not sure how a wind player could play staccato without tonguing - it's kind of possible, but probably wouldn't sound very good.

Chris


Hi Alij,

its not really possible to play staccato notes without tongueing; Chris is absolutely right with the soft tonguing notation (slurs with dots underneath - this messed with my head for many years!).

Agree with the above. What sort of effect are you looking for alij, and which instrument?
ViolinQueen
So... does this mean that for a note within a slur, with a dot above/beneath it mean a soft attack using the tongue, but it should be less smooth than a legato tongue? I'm confused sad.gif
Arundodonuts
QUOTE(ViolinQueen @ Dec 3 2011, 08:39 PM) *

So... does this mean that for a note within a slur, with a dot above/beneath it mean a soft attack using the tongue, but it should be less smooth than a legato tongue? I'm confused sad.gif

I understand it to mean the lightest tongue possible.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.