Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Flute Players: Chopin - Variations on a theme by Rossini
Forums > Viva Network > Viva Woodwind
Lemontree
Hi all,

once again a Jean-Pierre Rampal score with mistakes that (to say it with German slang) would frighten a pig to death. Sorry about that rambling but that it the umptiest Rampal score I hold in my hands that is littering with errors.

I know Chopin's Variations on a Theme by Rossiny are available from different editors. The edition I have is from IMC International Music Company.

If any of you have a copy by another editor, it would be very welcome if you could check for me the trill in Variations II bar 7. Does the F there have a neutral sign as well? I have heard it been played now in several variations.

Please could you also check in the same variation bar 13. Is it B E A E F# B C B or B E A G F#B C B?

And could you please write, who copy-edited your edition.

Thank you so much!

Lemontree
dorfmouse
QUOTE(Lemontree @ Mar 7 2012, 06:55 PM) *
G[/b] F#B C


Bar 7: In my Ed.Cesarini the trill, main note F#, is approached from E and F natural.
In the version I got from IMSLP the approach notes are E and F#.

Bar 13: Cesarini has E and the other has G.


Lemontree
Thanks dorfmouse, I hadn't thought about IMSLP yet. I will have a look at that, too. Thanks for the suggestion and the help.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.