QUOTE(trumpet geek @ Jun 2 2005, 03:19 PM)
in my opinion u have to have a good voice to start off with you cannot learn how to sing, is this very naive?
A young child may not sing in tune initially - but at some age will be in tune. I don't know the research on this, but there are totally tuneful singers at age 3, and more tuning up at age 6 say.
I have also heard adults tune up over time. I do not know if you could go to a teacher and get there quickly using some special technical approach. It is likely that such a person has become immersed in a musical environment and has made the grade by singing along with the radio, CD, piano, guitar or whatever.
Singing teachers I know normally audition pupils, presumably because of the difficulty of coaching a skill at such a very basic level.